FREE NEWSLETTER

Happiness lies not in the choice, but in making a decision and eliminating the uncertainty created by choice.

Latest PostsAll Discussions »

Wrapping it Up

"Jo, thanks for reading and commenting; I'm happy you liked this piece. It sounds like you've found a work-life balance that...well, works. I can envision continuing to work a bit five years from now, assuming I still enjoy it and a demand remains for my services."
- Ken Cutler
Read more »

Any concern?

"Economic chaos is transitory, and I tend not to be concerned about it, but there's a tiny bit of stress this time because the sudden demise of my lead client is about to put a big dent in my income -- and finding new clients at 70 in this environment may be a tad challenging. But I'm not losing sleep."
- Mike Gaynes
Read more »

Social Security Spousal Benefits

"Yes. So no reason for spouse to delay past FRA as receive maximum survivor benefit if worker delayed to 70."
- James McGlynn CFA RICP®
Read more »

Private Credit Stress?

"I put private credit and private equity in my "too hard" pile. Between the opacity and the lockup periods, I can't justify the trade-off for a few (maybe) extra return points. If they get to the point that they need to raise funds from 401(k) savers, I say let them go through the public markets, with all of the associated disclosures and regulations. Most won't need them to reach their goals."
- Kenneth DeLuca
Read more »

Ninety Nine, I mean Eight Retirement Tips

"Kenneth Tobin, 1% of 1% of every line they cast, can pay for a fair amount of advertisements and mailings. "
- Michael Flack
Read more »

$3 Trillion S&P 500 Gatecrashers

HAVE YOU GIVEN any thought to what's about to happen to your S&P 500 tracker? Three enormous IPOs are expected later this year: SpaceX, OpenAI, and Anthropic. Based on their most recent private transactions, SpaceX appears to be valued at around $1.25 trillion, OpenAI at roughly $800 billion, and Anthropic at approximately $380 billion. Combined, we could be looking at close to $3 trillion in private market value that wants to go public. To put that in perspective, the entire S&P 500 is worth roughly $60 trillion. That's not a routine year for markets. That could be a very large event indeed. I suspect the vast majority of people with money sitting in a tracker fund have absolutely no idea it's coming. Those that do might have read some of the more sensational claims I've seen about immediate, disruptive wholesale change to the S&P 500. I think those articles are getting ahead of themselves. These companies might not automatically land in your S&P 500 tracker the day they list. The index has hard rules, and two of them seem particularly relevant. A company generally needs to have been profitable for four consecutive quarters before it qualifies. OpenAI and Anthropic are both, as far as we can tell, burning through enormous amounts of capital. They may well not meet that bar at IPO. There's also a float requirement, where roughly half of a company's outstanding shares typically need to be publicly tradeable. These businesses will almost certainly debut with tiny floats, possibly somewhere between 5% and 10% of shares in public hands. That could disqualify them from day one. SpaceX is possibly the closest to profitability of the three, but the float issue likely applies across the board. One area of uncertainty is the selection committee. This has some discretion around the inclusion of larger IPOs. They could choose to move faster than the rules imply. So the story might not be your tracker being immediately and dramatically restructured. The story could be more drawn out than that, and perhaps more interesting for it. What does this mean in the short term? I can only offer informed speculation. To my mind, volatility seems likely around the listings themselves. Not necessarily because of forced index rebalancing, but because the float issue creates its own kind of pressure. Enormous companies carrying enormous implied valuations, but only a sliver of shares in circulation. Limited supply, near-unlimited institutional demand, and a market full of retail investors who've been reading about these companies for years and finally get their shot. I would guess we should expect wild price swings during those early trading days, though I could be wrong about the scale of it. Rotation risk is worth watching too, I think. Investors might pull money out of existing AI bets, the likes of Nvidia and Microsoft, and move it directly into OpenAI and Anthropic the moment they're publicly available. If that happens, the stocks that have driven your tracker's returns for the last three years could face sustained selling pressure, not because anything's wrong with those businesses, but simply because a shinier, newer version of the same trade has just arrived. A throwaway thought for anyone holding individual shares rather than trackers. The companies most at risk of ejection are those sitting at the bottom of the index. When a business loses its S&P 500 membership, every passive fund becomes an automatic seller. That can hit the share price hard, nothing wrong with the company, just forced selling as a side effect of something big happening at the very top. Worth knowing if any of those smaller names are in your portfolio. Medium term it could get more interesting still. If and when these companies do meet the profitability and float requirements, which could, I think, be years after their IPOs rather than months, every S&P 500 tracker on the planet becomes an automatic buyer. Hundreds of billions flowing into SpaceX, OpenAI and Anthropic whether fund managers want it or not. The mechanics of passive investing would turn every tracker holder into an investor in these three companies with absolutely no say in the matter. That's the bit people rarely stop to think about. Passive investing isn't neutral. It just means someone else is making your decisions for you. Then I come to the big question: do these businesses actually deserve these valuations? It's worth noting that every major IPO of recent years has tended to trade down from its private valuation once the public gets a proper look at the books. The venture capital guys who set those private prices aren't always right, and public markets have a habit of finding that out fairly quickly. If the same happens here, your tracker should hopefully be buying them at a fair price by the time they filter into the realm of inclusion within that tracker. It has to be said, that's not guaranteed. I'm not trying to be alarmist. These aren't penny stocks being hyped and I think that matters. OpenAI's revenue had already surpassed $20 billion by the end of 2025. SpaceX is targeting what could be the largest public offering in history. Anthropic has BlackRock, Blackstone, Microsoft and Nvidia on its books. These are real businesses generating real money with the biggest and most sophisticated names in global finance and technology behind them. That doesn't make them cheap at these prices, but it does make them a very different proposition from the usual IPO hype cycle. The bottom line for the average investor? We probably don't need to do anything dramatic. But it doesn't hurt to understand that the passive, set-and-forget vehicle you own may look quite different over the next few years, not necessarily in a single sudden lurch, but gradually, as these companies either earn their way into the index or don't. The index you bought into always changes but the next few years will definitely see bigger changes than normal. If nothing else, it'll be interesting to see what happens going forward…Eyes open.
Mark Crothers is a retired small business owner from the UK with a keen interest in personal finance and simple living. Married to his high school sweetheart, with daughters and grandchildren, he knows the importance of building a secure financial future. With an aversion to social media, he prefers to spend his time on his main passions: reading, scratch cooking, racket sports, and hiking.
Read more »

My Window is Open – Come In

"Thanks for writing a positive and timeless message."
- Jack Hannam
Read more »

The Bear Market Survival Kit (Pharmaceuticals Not Included)

"There will be a sizeable correction one day. You can bet on it. We each should answer the question "Are you in thought, or in action?" and you are in action."
- normr60189
Read more »

Focus on the real healthcare financial risk in post age 65 retirement

"There should be one formulary covering every FDA approved drug used for its approved purpose."
- R Quinn
Read more »

America Doesn’t Just Do Layoffs. It’s Fallen in Love With Them

"A business isn't a democracy: it's a for-profit organisation owned by the people who put their capital at risk. Ownership carries the right of control, full stop, and that holds whether you have two employees or twenty thousand. Employees are absolutely entitled to the wages they've earned and to respect — but that entitlement stops well short of representation on strategic and operational decisions. That authority belongs to the owners, or to the management they choose to delegate it to. Handing control to people who bear none of the financial risk is simply unfair to those who put up the money. I ran a small business with around fifty employees. The idea that I should have been legally or morally required to consult them on running my own company is frankly absurd. Want a say in how the business is run? Put financial skin in the game. That changes the equation entirely ."
- Mark Crothers
Read more »

Wrapping it Up

"Jo, thanks for reading and commenting; I'm happy you liked this piece. It sounds like you've found a work-life balance that...well, works. I can envision continuing to work a bit five years from now, assuming I still enjoy it and a demand remains for my services."
- Ken Cutler
Read more »

Any concern?

"Economic chaos is transitory, and I tend not to be concerned about it, but there's a tiny bit of stress this time because the sudden demise of my lead client is about to put a big dent in my income -- and finding new clients at 70 in this environment may be a tad challenging. But I'm not losing sleep."
- Mike Gaynes
Read more »

Social Security Spousal Benefits

"Yes. So no reason for spouse to delay past FRA as receive maximum survivor benefit if worker delayed to 70."
- James McGlynn CFA RICP®
Read more »

Private Credit Stress?

"I put private credit and private equity in my "too hard" pile. Between the opacity and the lockup periods, I can't justify the trade-off for a few (maybe) extra return points. If they get to the point that they need to raise funds from 401(k) savers, I say let them go through the public markets, with all of the associated disclosures and regulations. Most won't need them to reach their goals."
- Kenneth DeLuca
Read more »

Ninety Nine, I mean Eight Retirement Tips

"Kenneth Tobin, 1% of 1% of every line they cast, can pay for a fair amount of advertisements and mailings. "
- Michael Flack
Read more »

$3 Trillion S&P 500 Gatecrashers

HAVE YOU GIVEN any thought to what's about to happen to your S&P 500 tracker? Three enormous IPOs are expected later this year: SpaceX, OpenAI, and Anthropic. Based on their most recent private transactions, SpaceX appears to be valued at around $1.25 trillion, OpenAI at roughly $800 billion, and Anthropic at approximately $380 billion. Combined, we could be looking at close to $3 trillion in private market value that wants to go public. To put that in perspective, the entire S&P 500 is worth roughly $60 trillion. That's not a routine year for markets. That could be a very large event indeed. I suspect the vast majority of people with money sitting in a tracker fund have absolutely no idea it's coming. Those that do might have read some of the more sensational claims I've seen about immediate, disruptive wholesale change to the S&P 500. I think those articles are getting ahead of themselves. These companies might not automatically land in your S&P 500 tracker the day they list. The index has hard rules, and two of them seem particularly relevant. A company generally needs to have been profitable for four consecutive quarters before it qualifies. OpenAI and Anthropic are both, as far as we can tell, burning through enormous amounts of capital. They may well not meet that bar at IPO. There's also a float requirement, where roughly half of a company's outstanding shares typically need to be publicly tradeable. These businesses will almost certainly debut with tiny floats, possibly somewhere between 5% and 10% of shares in public hands. That could disqualify them from day one. SpaceX is possibly the closest to profitability of the three, but the float issue likely applies across the board. One area of uncertainty is the selection committee. This has some discretion around the inclusion of larger IPOs. They could choose to move faster than the rules imply. So the story might not be your tracker being immediately and dramatically restructured. The story could be more drawn out than that, and perhaps more interesting for it. What does this mean in the short term? I can only offer informed speculation. To my mind, volatility seems likely around the listings themselves. Not necessarily because of forced index rebalancing, but because the float issue creates its own kind of pressure. Enormous companies carrying enormous implied valuations, but only a sliver of shares in circulation. Limited supply, near-unlimited institutional demand, and a market full of retail investors who've been reading about these companies for years and finally get their shot. I would guess we should expect wild price swings during those early trading days, though I could be wrong about the scale of it. Rotation risk is worth watching too, I think. Investors might pull money out of existing AI bets, the likes of Nvidia and Microsoft, and move it directly into OpenAI and Anthropic the moment they're publicly available. If that happens, the stocks that have driven your tracker's returns for the last three years could face sustained selling pressure, not because anything's wrong with those businesses, but simply because a shinier, newer version of the same trade has just arrived. A throwaway thought for anyone holding individual shares rather than trackers. The companies most at risk of ejection are those sitting at the bottom of the index. When a business loses its S&P 500 membership, every passive fund becomes an automatic seller. That can hit the share price hard, nothing wrong with the company, just forced selling as a side effect of something big happening at the very top. Worth knowing if any of those smaller names are in your portfolio. Medium term it could get more interesting still. If and when these companies do meet the profitability and float requirements, which could, I think, be years after their IPOs rather than months, every S&P 500 tracker on the planet becomes an automatic buyer. Hundreds of billions flowing into SpaceX, OpenAI and Anthropic whether fund managers want it or not. The mechanics of passive investing would turn every tracker holder into an investor in these three companies with absolutely no say in the matter. That's the bit people rarely stop to think about. Passive investing isn't neutral. It just means someone else is making your decisions for you. Then I come to the big question: do these businesses actually deserve these valuations? It's worth noting that every major IPO of recent years has tended to trade down from its private valuation once the public gets a proper look at the books. The venture capital guys who set those private prices aren't always right, and public markets have a habit of finding that out fairly quickly. If the same happens here, your tracker should hopefully be buying them at a fair price by the time they filter into the realm of inclusion within that tracker. It has to be said, that's not guaranteed. I'm not trying to be alarmist. These aren't penny stocks being hyped and I think that matters. OpenAI's revenue had already surpassed $20 billion by the end of 2025. SpaceX is targeting what could be the largest public offering in history. Anthropic has BlackRock, Blackstone, Microsoft and Nvidia on its books. These are real businesses generating real money with the biggest and most sophisticated names in global finance and technology behind them. That doesn't make them cheap at these prices, but it does make them a very different proposition from the usual IPO hype cycle. The bottom line for the average investor? We probably don't need to do anything dramatic. But it doesn't hurt to understand that the passive, set-and-forget vehicle you own may look quite different over the next few years, not necessarily in a single sudden lurch, but gradually, as these companies either earn their way into the index or don't. The index you bought into always changes but the next few years will definitely see bigger changes than normal. If nothing else, it'll be interesting to see what happens going forward…Eyes open.
Mark Crothers is a retired small business owner from the UK with a keen interest in personal finance and simple living. Married to his high school sweetheart, with daughters and grandchildren, he knows the importance of building a secure financial future. With an aversion to social media, he prefers to spend his time on his main passions: reading, scratch cooking, racket sports, and hiking.
Read more »

My Window is Open – Come In

"Thanks for writing a positive and timeless message."
- Jack Hannam
Read more »

Free Newsletter

Get Educated

Manifesto

NO. 24: OUR ONLY earthly immortality will be the memories of others. We should make sure those memories are good—by spending our wealth on special times with friends and family.

Truths

NO. 16: WE’RE TOO self-confident. We imagine we’re smarter than other investors and can beat the market averages. This leads us to trade too much, make big investment bets and buy actively managed mutual funds. What if we’re at least partially successful? We may attribute our gains to our own brilliance—leading us to take yet more risk.

think

REAL RETURNS. Just because our investments climb in value doesn’t mean we’re making financial progress. Instead, we need to earn a “real” return—one that outpaces inflation. Over the long haul, savings accounts will deliver a negative real return, bonds should offer a modest real gain and stocks could outpace inflation by a healthy margin.

act

SUPPOSE YOU LOST your job. How long could you go before your financial life unraveled? This isn’t an issue for retirees—which is why they need little or no emergency money. But if you’re working, your plan for unemployment might include a cash reserve, slashing discretionary spending, a home equity line of credit and withdrawing Roth contributions.

Manage that tax bill

Manifesto

NO. 24: OUR ONLY earthly immortality will be the memories of others. We should make sure those memories are good—by spending our wealth on special times with friends and family.

Spotlight: Spending

A Very Politically Incorrect Ramble With a Potentially Real Point: Is Your Retirement Calculator Sexist?

I’m seriously sticking my neck out with this speculative, non politically correct observation and expect to get it chopped off by someone. And deservedly so!
Last week, my wife, Suzie, spent a considerable sum of money on hair care, nail salons, and other female-focused purchases. Certainly enough to make my right eyebrow twitch slightly. I only highlight this for the sake of my speculation, not as a manly moan about female spending choices. But the spending got me thinking about retirement calculators.

Read more »

Flexing the Retirement Spending Muscle

Suzie and I are packing a travel bag right now. Later this morning, we’re off to the Fermanagh Lakelands, a two-hour drive from our holiday home. We’re staying for three nights in a fancy hotel that’s also the wedding venue for the daughter of a very close friend. We’ll be attending the festivities there. I’m looking forward to the wedding, except, of course, for the suit I’ll have to wear.
I’m particularly interested in seeing the bride in her wedding dress because,

Read more »

Dreams I Had

When you were in your 20s and 30s, what did you dream of doing—and why weren’t those dreams realized? Here are four of the daydreams I had, but which remained just that:
Buy a sports car and drive across the country. This one got nixed by a host of factors—not enough vacation time, lack of money, the arrival of my first child at age 25. But truth be told, what seemed like a fun adventure slowly lost its allure,

Read more »

Quinn’s super frugal experiment. Are you up for a challenge?

Five years ago I wrote a HD article titled Food for Thought. It was about all the food we waste and, of course the money as a result.
Yesterday I mentioned to Connie that we have things in our pantry and fridge we don’t even know we have. She was sure that was not the case. Today I pulled out a bag of candy and other goodies we had forgotten from Christmas. I’m assuming it’s from last Christmas but that is not a certainty. 

Read more »

Frugality for fun and profit… but please, not necessity 

On occasion I have claimed to be frugal. But after a bit of research, I’m not sure that is always true. For sure we have avoided debt except a mortgage. Our last car loan was thirty years ago and we never had credit card debt, but beyond that my claim of frugality slips a bit. I think we may just be prudent.
When I read a comment about being frugal as part of living in retirement,

Read more »

Have you seen your money lately? 

I just realized the only time I see my money is when I withdraw from an ATM. Ye gads, my wealth accumulated over 70 years is all in cyberspace.
I am at the mercy of computer systems and the folks who run them – and maybe someone in a tiny village in Mongolia. Everything hinges on a programing language which are all Greek to me. 
Even my last ATM attempt didn’t go well. There is only one branch of my bank on the Cape.

Read more »

Spotlight: Crothers

New Voices

Isn't it great? We’ve had forum posts from five new contributors recently! It’s wonderful to see fresh voices joining the conversation. Keep it up into the new year, people—I’m loving the new perspectives you're bringing! Who else has a story or an idea to share? We’d love to hear from you!
Read more »

My New Zero-Wage CEO Role

This morning, as I was drinking my coffee, I realized it was September 1st. Today, with the kids returning to school in Ireland, grandparents across the country will be taking on after-school care duties. This got me thinking. Just after I retired and before heading to my vacation home, I had an eight-week window into one aspect of my retirement future: helping out a couple of days per week minding the grandkids. This was a new and unique adventure that I'm looking forward to resuming in late September. My initial impressions of this new responsibility have been enlightening. Although my grandson spent part of the summer with us, entertaining him one-on-one is a different kettle of fish. I've discovered that school drop-off is a dog-eat-dog world, where you jostle for the perfect parking space. It’s highly exciting when you spot a place right at the school gate, with envious "yummy mummies" looking on in anger. Very satisfying, and worth missing that second coffee. Then there's soccer at the local park after school. I’m positioned in the goal while my grandson kicks the ball at me as hard as he can, seeking the perfect goal. It hurts when the ball hits me right in the leg! I've had ball-shaped bruises to prove it. Quickly moving on from this indignity, we come to his favorite Xbox video game, Fortnite. I've mastered the basics but keep getting killed within minutes. I’m going to need a refresher course in September. My grandson thinks I'm a bit rubbish at it, but my goal is to last a bit longer before getting laughed at. Then we have my younger granddaughter. She’s not yet experienced the joys of school but loves trying to shove plastic cups into my mouth while making me dinner with her toy kitchen.…
Read more »

My Favourite Day: Retirement Payday Wednesday

I like Wednesday now; it's my favorite day of the week. When I was organizing everything before selling my business and retiring, I was so uptight and stressed about sorting out a cash flow stream for our everyday spending. I decided to pay ourselves weekly, reasoning it would make things easier to track what we spent this way. If you think about it, it's a silly thing to do. It's not like it was a surprise to me what we spent; I'd been funding that for countless years. I ran a small business with a multimillion-dollar turnover. My focus was on optimizing cash flow, generating income, and maximizing profit to keep the enterprise healthy and flourishing. Paying staff and suppliers was an easy thing for me to do. Surprisingly, I had a harder time paying myself. Taking the business's life-giving cash to fund my lifestyle always deeply bothered me. Definitely a weird tension for a business owner! But now I don't have this issue. It's just a joy to see the money drop into our account every week. I actually log into my online banking on a Wednesday morning, coffee in hand, just for the satisfaction of seeing the deposit. I'm easily pleased! Prior to pulling the trigger, I had spreadsheets about retirement income streams coming out of my ears. I would obsess over them nearly every day and get an itch if I hadn't looked in a while. Totally and utterly over the top. Nowadays, I really don't even think about them. I've set my sail, chartered my course, and it's on autopilot. It's a revelation to seemingly receive cash on a weekly basis without having perceived to hustle and work for it. It's a wonderful feeling that I know will fade when it becomes mundane everyday, but at…
Read more »

A Nightmare on Destitution Street

It's Halloween, l thought we could have a little scary story today…Booo👻 Mark stared into the glowing screen, watching the blood drain from his reflection. Twenty-three years feeding the warehouse beast, and the numbers whispered their cruel truth: $47,000. A ghost of what might have been. The employer match had waited, an unopened door. But there were other hungers, other demons whispering of pleasures that couldn't wait, of tomorrows that never arrived. "Should've saved more," he breathed into the frigid air, where only walls heard his confession. But rent had climbed like ivy over a grave, and he'd always had a taste for life's sweeter poisons. At sixty-two, something snapped within. He screamed at his manager, raised that finger, and walked. The money was his, wasn't it? He filed early, snatched Social Security with trembling hands, accepted the 30% reduction like a pact signed in blood. Forever. He never thought about it being forever reduced. The advisor's voice wailed through his memory: *"Never withdraw more than 4%” But Mark needed more. Needed to keep the music playing. He pulled 7%, watched his nest egg wither, a body drained by some undead vampire, its wants never satisfied.. By seventy, the 401k had flatlined in the rigor mortis of early death. Zero. Nothing left but the ghost of Social Security, thin as gruel, cold as rain. Now he shuffles through the food bank line. Surrounded by others wearing a hollowed look, eyes that have seen the monster's face. Retirement wasn't supposed to taste like this, like blood, metallic and bitter. The golden dream had curdled into dread and fear: this queue, this wait, this slow-motion haunting. Thirty more years, perhaps. Time stretches ahead like an endless horror. On Halloween night, Mark sits on his step handing out treats. The children's costumes shimmer…
Read more »

From Rakhi to Community: Lessons in Family for the Humble Dollar Family

My wife is the child of an Irish mother and a Punjabi father, a family dynamic that has taken on a much deeper meaning for me as I've gotten older. I can't speak for the nearly one billion people on the Indian subcontinent or the vast diaspora of Indian families around the world, but the extended Punjabi family I've known for forty years makes family the bedrock of their lives. I've essentially been adopted into their family and culture. I suppose once they realized I wasn't going anywhere, they decided they might as well educate this "Irish savage" in Indian culture and their way of thinking. This experience has meaningfully shifted my mindset. I've achieved reasonable material success through a combination of luck, happenstance, and years of hard work. Reaching retirement has given me the perspective to see that while this materialistic side of life is essential, it's not the most important element. What matters most to me is the connection with my immediate and close extended family. At this moment, I'm wearing a Rakhi bracelet, tied to my wrist by my "cousin sister" during Raksha Bandhan. It will remain on my wrist until it falls off, a daily reminder of the close, deep-rooted family who cares for me as one of their own. I've come to realize that the things I spent a lifetime accumulating—wealth, status, and possessions—don't provide the same fulfillment as human connection. Without this bond, my retirement would be diminished and a mere shadow of its true potential. But my Punjabi family has also taught me something else: that families have responsibilities to each other, especially during times of loss and uncertainty. When someone passes, you don't scatter—you come together. You honor their memory by protecting what they built and caring for those they leave behind.…
Read more »

The Slumping Deck: A Lesson in Time, Money and Memory

I'm standing on my garden deck this morning, a definite slump in the middle causing me slight dismay. I know the cause for a fact: a main structural beam has failed. I built that decking over twenty years ago just after my brother passed away. Looking back, I now realize I started the project as a way to keep busy and cope with grief. Yet, here and now, the question resurfaces: should I spend money to have someone fix it, or should I invest my time and do it myself? For me, it's an easy choice; I enjoy working with wood and find great satisfaction in completing projects like this. The satisfaction of creation, the calm of focused work, and the personal story these efforts bring into our lives often outweigh a purely financial calculation. I'm reminded of Charlie Munger's phrase, "Invert, always invert." Interpreting this idea more loosely, I can see how others might view this equation very differently. This personal dilemma is a small microcosm in the spirit of the "time value of money" problem. Should your time be better spent elsewhere on things that appeal to you, and could your money be more wisely deployed on other investments? The crux of the matter is the realization that both time and money are finite resources, and we must use our best judgment on how to consume these valuable commodities to the betterment of our own lives. Who would have thought that such complex financial concepts could extend to simply fixing a common garden deck? But on this occasion, I only have to know it will remind me of my brother. We had a wonderful childhood together.
Read more »